I suppose it’s lucky that I went to Philadelphia early on in my stadium tour. In 2006, I didn’t yet have the hatred for the Phillies that I would soon develop. Sure, they had a strong core of players, such as all-star second baseman Chase Utley, shortstop Jimmy Rollins, rising star Shane Victorino, rookie pitcher Cole Hamels and that year’s National League MVP, first baseman Ryan Howard. But for a Mets fan, the only division rival that had mattered for the last decade was Atlanta. And in 2006, the Mets were doing all they could to ensure that they were now the beasts in the NL East. On the day of my trip to Citizens Bank Park, the Phillies were 3 games under .500, and 14 games behind my Mets (a cushion the Metropolitans would all but hold onto for the rest of the season). The Phils would go on a bit of a tear and finish 8 games over .500, but they’d still end up 12 games back in the division, and 3 out of the Wild Card, while the Mets would end the season one bad Aaron Heilman pitch short of a World Series appearance. Of course, I didn’t know any of that yet.
I also didn’t know that the next season, the aforementioned Jimmy Rollins would declare that the Phillies were “the team to beat” in the NL East during Spring Training. Nor did I know that Mets would lose 12 of the last 17 games in 2007 and blow a 7-game lead to give the Phillies their first NL East title in 13 years. And I certainly didn’t know that the Mets would blow it again in 2008, missing the playoffs again. And I really didn’t know that Philly would win 5 straight NL East titles, that they’d even manage to win a damn World Series, that Cole Hamels would call the Mets “Choke Artists” on late night television, that they’d go to a second straight World Series (and actually leave some Mets fans happy when the Yankees of all teams won the World Series). I had no idea that they’d eventually compile arguably the most dominant pitching rotation in the history of the modern game. I didn’t know that one of their fans would intentionally vomit on an 11-year old girl. I wasn’t yet aware that I’d soon grow to detest them more than any professional sports team that isn’t the Miami Dolphins (I sure do hate the Miami Dolphins). But I suppose I’m getting a little worked up. This is supposed to be about the ballpark, not about how much I now dislike the team that plays there because their success has coincided with my team’s heartbreak for half a decade now. So I’ll try for a moment to put that all aside, and see if I can avoid letting that distaste color my memories of their ballpark. I’m not gonna lie, it might be a tough task. But while I hate its baseball team, I do love the City of Brotherly Love itself. So perhaps that will help my ability to remain somewhat impartial.
My cousin Hillary met her now-husband Doug when they were undergrads at Villanova. After graduation, they stayed in the Philadelphia area for a few years before moving to NYC. Doug is a lifelong Mets fan, and like me, he didn’t really like the Phillies since they were our division rival, but he didn’t yet hate them yet. And living in Philadelphia and working in sports management at the time, he was always up for going to a game. Hillary is also an avid sports fan, and shares Doug’s love for the Metsies. So when I told them about my west coast trip and how I’d started to think about seeing all the parks in baseball, I was extended an open invitation to come to Philly anytime for a game. I had done the obvious math earlier in that summer, and determined that to see all the parks before 2015, I should shoot to get to 3 parks a year. And with Hillsy and Doug being a relatively short train ride from New York, Philadelphia was an obvious choice to round out to my first full season of touring and Citizens Bank Park was added to the calendar as my seventh Major League ballpark.
I’d never even been to Philadelphia before, so the weekend was a bit of a whirlwind. Friday night involved a night of fun out on the town in their neighborhood of Manayunk, and Saturday was filled with the requisite sightseeing: The Liberty Bell, Independence Hall, the Statue of William Penn atop City Hall, Franklin Court, etc. We drove past the Art Museum to see Rocky’s stairsteps. And, as luck would have it, it was the second-to-last day for an exhibit celebrating Philadelphia Sports history at the National Constitution Center (which was a really great exhibit). So we certainly got our exercise in as they took me around to see the sights.
As we headed down to South Philly, we made the trek to Pat’s King of Steaks, where I put my lactose intolerance on hold for a night and got a “provolone wit’” [cheesesteak with provolone & onions]. They told me Pat’s is the original, and I don’t even need to bother with Geno’s if and when I go back. That sandwich was everything I ever imagined it would be.
Unless you count the beer on the bus on the way to Camden Yards, Citizens Bank Park provided me with my first Major League tailgate. Granted, the 3 of us basically washed down our cheesesteaks by splitting a sixer, so it’s not we’re not talking about a rager of any sort. But it’s still fun to sit and have a brewski while watching the various types of fans that pour into a stadium. I must say, on this night, I didn’t see any types of activities that might earn the dubious reputation that’s often cast upon Philadelphia sports fans. Everyone around us in the parking lot and in our section were nothing if not well behaved. I have seen some fans get pretty rowdy at Phillies/Mets games in New York. I was a bit weary of what I might be getting myself into as I entered the belly of the beast, especially since Doug and I agreed that we’d be rooting for Washington, so he was wearing a Nationals hat and I was wearing my retro Expos hat. But for my money, I almost wish I had more colorful stories to tell, since Philly fans have more than once been declared “the worst fans in sports” by major publications. I saw none of the darker side on that night. And the few Phillies fans I know personally are all excellent people and are just as passionate about their team as I am, which I do respect. And we can all agree on Tug McGraw and Lenny Dykstra (and Richie Ashburn was an original Met). So I’ll leave my commentary on the Phils’ fan base to that.
Speaking of Richie Ashburn, we entered the park into Ashburn Alley, as our seats were out in Left Field. I was so impressed by the view of the park from this large outfield promenade. One could spend the entire game watching from there and be perfectly happy without ever taking his or her seat. And I’m sure many Phillies fans take advantage of the fact that they can heckle the opposing team’s bullpen, which is a mere stone’s throw below the alley in right center. From the Ashburn statue and the Phillies Wall of Fame, to gift and memorabilia shops, to various games for kids young and old, Ashburn Alley provides an exciting, fan-friendly atmosphere. And I was blown away by the variety of local, seemingly authentic, Philadelphia establishments that had food stands in the alley and throughout the park. To this day, I can still taste the Old Bay from the Chickie and Pete’s Crab Fries, which was the only thing I could even contemplate eating after having Pat’s.
I didn’t walk much around the exterior of the park, which would become part of my ballpark tradition in years to come, but Citizens Bank Park was the first park I ever visited where I was able to walk the full interior perimeter of the park, without retracing my steps. While it seems simple, after coming from Shea (where one could easily miss innings at a time while waiting in line for food or restrooms) I still remember that it was a novel (and excellent) experience to be able to immerse myself in the stadium’s atmosphere and still be able to actually watch the game through the wide concourses and numerous open areas throughout the park. And once the game became a blowout (which I’ll get to in a moment), Hillsy, Doug and I did some exploring to see what the game looked like from different vantage points throughout the park, which was a lot of fun.
The victims, er… visitors, on this night were the Washington Nationals. In their second season of existence since moving to the Nation’s Capitol from Quebec, the Nationals were still showing signs of being depleted during the Expos years (in which they were nearly contracted entirely and were eventually owned and operated by Major League Baseball). Outfielder Alfonso Soriano was an All-Star starter that year, and third baseman Ryan Zimmerman was in the midst of an excellent rookie season, and would end up finishing just short of the Rookie of the Year award. But the Nationals had a number of obvious holes, and were 15 games under the .500 mark. Being a fan of the underdog, and knowing that a Nationals win would widen the Mets’ gap (not that it needed widening that season), our crew rooted for the visitors. This is one of the few times I’ve chosen to do that on the tour. Traditionally, unless the Mets are the visitors, I’ll root for the home team at a stadium. After all, I’m buying their hat as a souvenir: might as well wear it for the full nine. So that was one of the little details that made this park unique for me. Not that it did any good.
Philly did irreparable damage in the 2nd inning, putting the game away before many had even made it to their seats. Washington’s starting pitcher, Ramon Ortiz, walked two batters, gave up 3 singles (one of which was by the opposing pitcher, Hamels), a double and hit a batter to create a quick 5-run hole. He then hit Chase Utley with a pitch, creating a near-confrontation, as Utley thought about charging the mound before finally taking his base. Ortiz then gave up a 3-run homer to Ryan Howard, and he was ejected 2 batters later when he hit Aaron Rowand with a pitch for his second HBP in an inning. Ortiz threw 71 pitches in less than 2 innings, and took his 11th loss in his first 20 decisions, Ortiz’s stat line read as follows: 1.2 innings pitched, 5 hits, 8 runs (all earned), 3 walks, 1 home run, 1 strike out, an ERA of 43.19 and a WHIP of 4.80. Just about the only thing he didn’t do was give up a triple.
The Phillies brought 13 batters to the plate in the 2nd, and they got the full order up again in the 5th, as they scored 3 more runs off of relief pitcher Travis Hughes. The Nationals got on the board in the top of that 5th, with solo Home Runs from Alex Escobar and Alfonso Soriano, but that would be all the damage they could muster up in an 11-2 loss.
One of the drawbacks of sitting in the outfield at Citizens Bank Park is that we weren’t able to see the state-of-the-art scoreboard directly behind us. But at a park that’s notorious for being a “Band Box,” the excitement of knowing that a home run could come your way at any time makes up for it. In the park’s first 2 years of existence, more than 200 homers were hit in each season, many towards left field. The walls were adjusted before the 2006 season, but we still had 3 taters come towards us in our outfield seats-the aforementioned Soriano shot landed a few rows away from where we were sitting. And when one of those long balls is sent over the wall by a Phightin’ Phil, the giant Liberty Bell in center field lights up Red, White and Blue, and swings to the left and right as it “rings” in celebration. This stadium feature is an awesome touch, and even a devout Philly hater such as myself can acknowledge that it’s one of the most unique and fun celebrations in all of baseball.
And, speaking of unique, no discussion of the game in Philadelphia is complete without mentioning the Phillie Phanatic, arguably the most recognizable mascot in the game. I’m pretty sure he’s a giant muppet, although I’m not entirely sure. If not that, I couldn’t tell you what he is. I have no idea why he’s green. I think the fact that he came to being in the late 70’s (just as I did) can explain most of the questions. But he causes a good deal of mischief and mayhem, and the fans in Philly sure do love him. I’d bet Mr. Met could take him down in a fistfight though.
I had a great time at my Phillies game, and I have fond memories of that night: a chance to spend time with family who I love, the early stages of shaping some traditions that I still carry out with each new stadium, some great food, and an exciting, if not necessarily well-played, baseball game. What more can a guy ask for? Other than another 10,000 losses for the Phillies franchise, of course.